I had this photo labeled as James Joseph Murphy, but I’m starting to think this may be someone else. James J Murphy died in 1917 at 36 years old. This man looks a little older, don’t ya think? To give some comparison, the photo on the right is actually James J Murphy.
The hair part is different, but the eyes and cheeks are very similar. Could be him, his father, or someone completely different. What are your thoughts? Does anyone know where the photo on the left came from?